PDN WEB  
COMPASS
PDNonline    Forums    Photo Critique    To crop or not?

Read-Only Read-Only Topic
Go
New
Find
Notify
Tools
To crop or not?
 Login/Join
 
Posted
Does this image work as is, or should it be cropped tighter?

 
Posts: 8 | Location: Fresno | Registered: 25 December 2004Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
Sorry, not sure how to post images here yet...

http://lennon.csufresno.edu/~hollak/index.htm

EDIT BY MODERATOR: I re-posted your image for you above. The best thing to do is to resize your images in Photoshop at either 500-550 width, then save as a JPEG and use IMG tags to post.

See instructions and guidelines here. Smiler
 
Posts: 8 | Location: Fresno | Registered: 25 December 2004Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
Play around and see what happens. :shrug:
 
Posts: 138 | Location: NYC | Registered: 13 May 2004Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
I think it would be stronger cropped, although honestly, I don't
think it's got much charisma to begin with if you're going for a goofy portrait. Maybe a version with more expression in her face?
 
Posts: 110 | Location: MI | Registered: 27 June 2003Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
I tried cropping it a few different ways in Photoshop, but I'm not sure how much it gets you. The issue is twofold: it's a very straight portrait, and the hot light on that hand is very distracting.

So, for example, you could limit the amount of information being shown, to make the image more suggestive (rather than literal), but the hot light on the hand still distracts.



It seems like you know the direction you'd like to go, but you would need to try and either purposefully use contrast to your advantage, or try to smooth the lighting. Working with different angles, distances, and crops can make the portrait more interesting.

Good luck! Smiler
 
Posts: 356 | Location: New York | Registered: 23 October 2003Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
I completely agree about the blown out left-hand. This image was a spontaneous shot taken outdoors as the summer sun was setting, say about 7 pm. The sun is coming in almost horizontal and bouncing directly off of her left hand. So, it wasn't a controled environment, but a spur-of-the-moment action on her part.

I then have tried to drop the background out and turn to B&W in PS to try and make the shot more interesting. Maybe PS can help me with the blown-out left hand.

Thank you for the the comments.
 
Posts: 8 | Location: Fresno | Registered: 25 December 2004Report This Post
Posted Hide Post
I also agree with the brightness on the hand. It also causes major shadows the way it was cropped to the point that the picture shows less detail is a good idea. Even though the picture shows less it gives it more feeling.
 
Posts: 2 | Location: Phoenix,Az | Registered: 17 January 2005Report This Post
  Powered by Social Strata  

Read-Only Read-Only Topic

PDNonline    Forums    Photo Critique    To crop or not?

PDN Online is the leading photography news resource for photography professionals in the photo industry. With features, news and reviews, PDN provides expert advice on everything related to the business of photography. By offering an array of imaging software and SLR digital camera reviews in our gear guide, users can read about the upcoming trends in photo technology. PDN also offers IPN Stock Photography for professional photo buyers to license. Visit our website each day to discover the latest photography news, from photographer biographies and features, to trends in digital products. Sign up for our free photography newsletter today!

Contact PDN | About Photo District News | Camera Reviews and Gear Guide | Photography Blog | Photo News | Photo Magazine- Print Subscription |
Photography RSS Resources | Free Photography Newsletter | Photo Magazine Advertising | Video Gallery | Photographer Features & Resources | Stock Photographs
© 2008 Nielsen Business Media All rights reserved. Read our TERMS OF USE & PRIVACY POLICY